I’m also a smoker. I have the insurance though, and pay the tobacco user fee. I read in the handbook (I think) that lying about tobacco user status is similar to defaulting on your REDcard; punishable by termination.
Yup, they also remind you that it can be punishable by termination when you make the determination online or on the phone. (I had to do mine on the phone because I missed the deadline to do it online). Since it more than doubled the cost of the insurance and like you, I'm in relatively decent health and probably wouldn't use it except for emergencies, I just went with the much cheaper coverages to cover that kind of thing.
I'm just surprised at some of the people are risking both their job and their family's insurance by lying about that. A couple of TLs and one ETL has told me they just said they weren't smokers. Which is also crazy because while I'm a trustworthy person and wouldnt rat them out, that's the sort of thing that I wouldn't tell a soul about.
Also, the ACA penalty was eliminated for the 2019 tax year, so that's not a concern. It definitely would have been, but luckily I wasn't eligible last year so it didn't affect my taxes. (It almost did, Target reported that i was eligible for 1 month of the year for some reason, even though there was no way for me to enroll. Was a bit of an issue getting that sorted). The HSA thing was a serious consideration, though. I almost did the FSA since you can get the $500 in that without the insurance, but it doesn't roll over like the HSA does, so has to be spent by the end of the year and I figured I likely wouldn't use it.
The person on the phone did tell me that you can have the smoker fee removed until the next plan year if you participate in the Quit Smoking plan. I forget the name. Even if you don't successfully quit it comes off until next year's registration. So that may be worth looking in to. Hell, may even actually help ya quit.